Simple & Healthier Holiday Baking Swaps
If you’re reading this, chances are we’re similar … we love the festive treats, the holiday baking days, the sprinkles, the cocoa, the cozy movie nights, all of it. And we want to create fun, magical desserts and snacks for our kids…
…without feeling overloaded by all the junk that somehow sneaks into everything this time of year.
As a health coach and a mom who has lived through every stage — from hyper-aware clean living to full burnout (and yes the burnout came after the hyper-aware…)— I have such a different perspective now. I don’t believe you need to do everything perfectly. In fact, chasing “perfect” usually creates more stress, more guilt, and more mental fatigue… and none of that supports our health or the energy we’re trying to cultivate in our homes.
Balance truly is a gift.
Maybe you do grab that one bag of M&Ms because they’re nostalgic and your kids light up when they add them to Christmas cookies. That’s okay! You can still lean on more natural, dye-free, real-ingredient options in other areas. It never has to be all or nothing.
For me, one of the few ingredients I genuinely do prioritize avoiding — especially at home — is artificial food dye. I’ve seen firsthand how my kids’ behavior, emotions, and even sleep can shift after certain dyes, and while some exposures (like school or events) are unavoidable, I focus on what I can control inside our home.
So below, I’m sharing my favorite healthier festive baking ingredients, naturally colored sprinkles, and cleaner pantry swaps that keep the magic, color, and fun — without the artificial dyes and unnecessary chemicals. These swaps are easy, accessible, and budget-conscious for moms who want to do a little better without doing it all.
Use this as your simple holiday baking guide, and feel free to save it for all your Christmas cookies, class party treats, gingerbread houses, and everything in between!
My Favorite Dye-Free & Better-For-You Holiday Baking Swaps
FOOD COLORING (naturally colored)
FESTIVE SRPINKLES & SANDING SUGARS (dye-free)
Supernatural Red Sanding Sugar
Supernatural Christmas Sprinkles
Sweets Indeed Christmas Sprinkles & Sanding Sugar
Trader Joe’s almost always has holiday sprinkles now, so be sure to check them out too
CLEANER CANDY OPTIONS
YumEarth Candy Canes (minis)
YumEarth Candy Canes (regular sized)
Unreal Chocolate Gems (alt for M&Ms)
YumEarth Holiday Gummies & BlackForest Brand Gummies (great for gingerbread house decorations!)
FAVORITE CHOCOLATE
HU Chocolate
Ghirardelli Peppermint Chocolates
Nativas Naturals Cacao Powder
Trader Joe’s Cacao Powder
Trader Joe’s Milk & Dark Chocolate Bars
BAKING ESSENTIALS
Bob’s Red Mill Aluminum-Free Baking Powder
Thrive Market for Healthy Pantry Essentials
If you’re looking to make healthier holiday baking a little easier — especially with pantry swaps, natural sprinkles, and dye-free ingredients — Thrive Market is truly one of my favorite places to shop. They carry so many of the items listed above, plus better-quality cocoa, clean baking staples, allergy-friendly snacks, and the exact dye-free brands I reach for each season.
This is also where I always stock up on our vitamins when they go on sale, my favorite cleaner skincare, and all the simple snack and sweet-treat swaps that help us stick to our wellness goals without feeling overwhelmed.
And if you’re new to Thrive Market, you can use the link below to get 40% off your first order, which makes it the perfect time to refresh your holiday pantry or try a few new better-for-you products.
Holistic Homemaking During the Holidays
You don’t need a perfectly clean pantry to be a great mom. You don’t need to overhaul your whole holiday menu. And you certainly don’t need to stress over every ingredient label. These simple alternatives let us keep the magic and joy of holiday baking — without the dyes and additives that don’t make our kids (or us) feel great.
This is the foundation of everything I try to encourage at Well-Rooted Motherhood and in our holistic homemaking:
✧ creating a nourishing environment
✧ supporting our children’s wellbeing
✧ honoring our own mental load
✧ and still keeping all the fun and nostalgia alive
These swaps simply give you easy wins that feel aligned with your values and your family’s health — without the overwhelm.
You might also like…
Junk-Free Stocking Stuffers
Some of our favorite stocking stuffers that include dye-free and better candy options, mindful activities and items they will *actually* use throughout the year!
A Festive Freebie for Your Littles
~ Favorite Things ~
Explore more on the Blog
kids & Family
Christmas
